Mental Health in Bhutanese Refugee Populations

Posted on by Tony Ao, Sc.D, EIS Officer, CDC Global Disease Detection Branch
Tony Ao, Sc.D, EIS Officer, CDC Global Disease Detection Branch
Tony Ao, Sc.D, EIS Officer, CDC Global Disease Detection Branch

Imagine that you‘ve been driven from your home, deprived of your possessions, made dependent on others, and forced to flee to a foreign country not once, not twice, but three times over the course of your life. You feel isolated and lost without a sense of citizenship or permanent community. Lhotshampas (“People of the South”) are Bhutanese of Nepali origin who have lived in Bhutan and maintained their distinct cultural and religious traditions since the 19th century. Starting in the early 1990s, confronted with increased cultural and religious persecution by the Bhutanese government, more than 100,000 Lhotshampas fled to refugee camps in neighboring Nepal. In these camps, the Lhotshampas faced host country labor and movement restrictions.

Beginning in 2008, Bhutanese refugees began resettling in the United States, and to date, more than 57,000 have resettled into communities across the country. Even though this may seem like a happy ending, we now see that the years of persecution and loss of citizenship have taken their toll on the mental health of the Bhutanese refugee population. From February 2009 to February 2012, the US Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) reported 16 suicides among Bhutanese refugees in the United States. This number far surpasses the number of suicides reported to ORR among any other refugee community in the United States, yielding a suicide rate that is twice as high as that in the general United States population. These statistics, along with a recommendation by the International Organization of Migration (IOM), prompted us to begin one of the first systematic investigations of mental health and suicide in this population.

We used a combination of psychological autopsies and cross-sectional surveys to gather our data. A psychological autopsy is a standard procedure used to investigate a death by interviewing a person who was close to the deceased to reconstruct his/her mental state and actions before death. These autopsies were conducted for 15 of the 16 suicide decedents across the country. We then conducted a survey of randomly selected Bhutanese refugees in 4 states (Georgia, Arizona, Texas, and New York) in order to gain a better overall understanding of the mental health status, including suicidal thoughts, of the Bhutanese refugee population in the United States. These surveys were conducted by trained members of the local Bhutanese community. Because suicide is a sensitive subject, especially within this particular culture, we took pains to ensure that those who conducted the interviews were trusted members of the community in order to increase the comfort and confidentiality of respondents.

The results of the psychological autopsies indicate that 40% of suicide decedents had reported symptoms suggestive of anxiety. Statelessness was found to be a common traumatic event experienced by the deceased, with language barriers being reported as one of the most common post-migration difficulties. In the overall refugee community, we found that about 21% of respondents reported symptoms of a mental health condition, much higher than the national average of 6.7%. More than half of the respondents had experienced traumatic events such as lack of nationality, having to flee suddenly, and lack of food, water, or safety.

Many of the Bhutanese in the United States reside in apartment complexes assigned to them by resettlement agencies. They live modestly, with large families often sharing one or two bedrooms. Neighbors come and go from each other’s homes in a sort of open-door policy. I felt welcomed by this tightknit group, having come with a community leader who served as my bridge during my site visits. But the mood was also somber. It was apparent that people wanted to help us, but a balance was required between getting information we needed and being respectful of a culture that values privacy.

We do know that there is a problem; there is a significant, yet undiagnosed, burden of mental health conditions in this population of refugees. Our report offers recommendations, including enhanced screening for mental health when refugees first arrive in the United States, establishing more culturally appropriate mental health resources in the community, and creating a centralized database to keep better track of reported suicides in all refugee communities. We hope that this survey and our accompanying recommendations can help increase awareness of mental health issues as a whole in order to build stronger communities, not only for Bhutanese refugees but for any groups facing resettlement challenges in the future.

For more information, read the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) article on this topic titled, Suicide and Suicidal Ideation Among Bhutanese Refugees — United States, 2009–2012.

Posted on by Tony Ao, Sc.D, EIS Officer, CDC Global Disease Detection BranchTags , , ,

3 comments on “Mental Health in Bhutanese Refugee Populations”

Comments listed below are posted by individuals not associated with CDC, unless otherwise stated. These comments do not represent the official views of CDC, and CDC does not guarantee that any information posted by individuals on this site is correct, and disclaims any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on any such information. Read more about our comment policy ».

    Yes Tony, your survey and recommendations can help to improve the overall situation. We cannot even imagine what they are facing in the state of statelessness and in which crises they are right now unless we visualize our own selves at their places.

    They fled to save their distinct cultural traditions but what’s happening to them. Here I would like to quote “The Last Lesson” by Alphonse Daudet in which the story depicts the pathos of the situation when Prussian forces attacked and captured France and reveals how people feel when they don’t learn their own language and lose their asset.

    In short, they are the people who are in great need of attention. We have to make them realize that

    “All is not lost”

    Samreen M

    Bolee.com

    Kudos to Tony and the team for a great investigation and report on the Bhutaneses refugees and suicide. We have a significant Bhutaneses refugees population herein Ohio and have been in touch with the population and heard about various sad stories including but not limited to intimidation, threats to property and bodily harm, suicide ideation. Some social workers and community members even point to factors as location environment being the cause of some of the troubles they are encountering. Often anecdotal stories surface about some refugees (especially those who were provided housing in some of the poor and insecure neighborhoods) being threatened to peddle drugs for some of the drug dealers; some were beaten up for money and threatened with bodily harm. This is one reason why many try to relocate to other states where they may have some friends and social support. Perhaps in addition to enhancing mental health services, we may need to take an integrated approach by looking also at their other needs, such as shelter, financial and legal (some get into trouble lacking a good understanding of the law) counseling. Thanks.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments posted become a part of the public domain, and users are responsible for their comments. This is a moderated site and your comments will be reviewed before they are posted. Read more about our comment policy »

Page last reviewed: August 20, 2013
Page last updated: August 20, 2013
Content source: